Choosing between the Benelli Supernova and the Remington 870 is a common dilemma for shotgun buyers. Both are legendary names in the industry, offering reliable performance and a variety of configurations. However, they cater to different needs and preferences. This in-depth comparison will help you decide which pump-action shotgun is the right fit for you.
Design and Ergonomics: A Tale of Two Approaches
The Remington 870, a classic design dating back decades, features a straightforward, robust construction. Its simplicity is both its strength and weakness. While incredibly reliable and easily maintained, the ergonomics might feel less refined than the Supernova for some users. The stock and forend are typically more basic, potentially leading to less comfortable extended use.
The Benelli Supernova, on the other hand, boasts a more modern and ergonomic design. The ComforTech system, featuring a recoil-reducing stock and a unique grip, significantly mitigates felt recoil. Its Inertia-Driven system (in the semi-auto versions; the pump action uses a different system) also contributes to a smoother shooting experience. The Supernova's adjustable stock and forend options provide enhanced customization for different body types and shooting styles.
Key Ergonomic Differences Summarized:
| Feature | Remington 870 | Benelli Supernova |
|---|---|---|
| Stock | Traditional, less ergonomic | ComforTech, recoil-reducing, adjustable |
| Forend | Basic | Ergonomic, adjustable |
| Overall Feel | Simple, functional | Refined, modern, customizable |
| Recoil Management | Higher | Lower |
Reliability and Durability: Standing the Test of Time
Both shotguns are renowned for their reliability. The Remington 870's legendary reputation stems from decades of proven performance in various conditions, from hunting fields to law enforcement. Its simplicity translates to ease of maintenance and repair. Parts are readily available, making upkeep straightforward.
The Benelli Supernova, while newer to the market than the 870, has also established a strong reputation for reliability. Benelli's reputation for quality is evident in the Supernova's robust construction. Its inertia-driven (semi-auto) or pump-action system is known for its smooth operation and consistent performance.
Features and Customization: Tailoring to Your Needs
The Remington 870 offers a wide array of configurations, from hunting models with wood stocks to tactical versions with ghost ring sights. However, customization options are often limited to aftermarket accessories.
The Benelli Supernova provides more built-in customization options. The adjustable stock and forend allow for a personalized fit, crucial for comfort and accuracy. This inherent adjustability reduces the need for extensive aftermarket modifications.
Feature Comparison:
| Feature | Remington 870 | Benelli Supernova |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Primarily aftermarket accessories | Built-in adjustable stock & forend |
| Barrel Options | Wide variety | Wide variety |
| Stock Options | Wide variety, but mostly fixed | More options, often adjustable |
| Accessories | Extensive aftermarket availability | Good availability |
Price Point: Weighing Value and Investment
Generally, the Remington 870 offers a more budget-friendly entry point. Its established design and readily available parts translate to a lower price tag.
The Benelli Supernova, with its advanced features and ergonomic design, typically commands a higher price. However, the improved comfort, recoil reduction, and customization options justify the increased cost for many users.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Shotgun
The "better" shotgun depends entirely on individual needs and priorities.
-
Choose the Remington 870 if: You prioritize affordability, require a simple and easily maintained shotgun, and are comfortable with a more basic design. Its reliability and vast aftermarket support are significant advantages.
-
Choose the Benelli Supernova if: You value ergonomics, recoil reduction, and built-in customization options. Its modern design and enhanced comfort make it ideal for extended shooting sessions. The higher price point is offset by a more refined and personalized shooting experience.
Ultimately, handling both shotguns is crucial before making a decision. Visit your local gun store to compare them firsthand and determine which one feels best in your hands and aligns with your shooting style and budget.
